The Many Voices of Dolly Parton
Dolly Parton died today at 80. I’m not going to try to sum up a six-decade career in one post, that feels wrong. Instead I want to talk about one thing: the sheer range of what her voice actually did.
Two Songs, One Sitting, a Hundred Different Lives After That
By her own account, Parton wrote “Jolene” and “I Will Always Love You” in the same writing session back in 1972. Two songs that ended up defining completely different eras of music. She recorded “Jolene” at RCA Studio B on May 22, 1973, then went back less than a month later, June 12, to record “I Will Always Love You.”
That second song has been reinterpreted more times than almost any other vocal performance in music history. Whitney Houston’s 1992 version, from The Bodyguard, is still one of the best-selling singles ever made, and it’s a completely different piece of work from Parton’s original. Different key, different phrasing, a totally different emotional weight, built from the same eleven words in the title. Two singers, two production teams, two eras, and both versions are iconic in their own right.
That’s not just good songwriting. That’s writing something strong enough to survive being taken apart and rebuilt by someone else entirely.
A Completely Different Kind of Performance
Not many people know Parton was Grammy-nominated for audiobook narration, for reading her own memoir, Behind the Seams: My Life in Rhinestones.
Singing and narrating a book aren’t the same job, even coming from the same person. Singing is about range and power. Narration is almost the opposite, it’s restraint, pacing, holding someone’s attention for hours with nothing but your voice and no melody to lean on. She got recognized for both. That’s not one talent, that’s several, and she happened to be great at more than one of them.
And She Didn’t Stop There
Music wasn’t even the whole story. She moved into film, “9 to 5,” “Steel Magnolias,” and into business, building Dollywood into one of the most successful family entertainment parks in the country. Songwriter, actress, entrepreneur, philanthropist, all at once, for sixty years, without any one of those ever getting in the way of the others.
That kind of range doesn’t happen by accident, and it definitely doesn’t happen for six decades straight.
One More Thing Worth Saying
Her catalog has been translated, dubbed, subtitled, and covered in languages all over the world. “Jolene” alone has been recorded in half a dozen languages by artists who never met her. Every one of those versions meant someone had to figure out how to carry what she wrote into a completely different language without losing what made it work.
That’s a different craft than the one she practiced. But it only exists because she wrote something worth carrying that far in the first place.
Comments are closed